I would not have been willing to pay for two nights and would have left. I want to stress something - at that point my Caesars rewards app showed I could get Friday comped, and the hotel clerk confirmed looking at her system that Friday should be comped.
She confirmed that the total for both days would be the price for Thursday nighr( plus tax). So, I said as long as I could stay two more nights for the price of Thursday night, ( since I'd get comped for Friday) I'd agree to stay. She confirmed I would get comped for Friday but explained there was not one available for that night (?Thursday). I went to front desk, said it was interesting that I earned Comp for two nights from now which was a Friday, but not for that night, and asked if I could I instead get comped for Thursday because I planned to stay one more night. I looked at the app and it showed regular rate of $236 for that Thursday night, 19th)but showed I get comp for Friday night( (20th) plus three days the following week). The next morning, I'd spent enough on the 18th to hopefully warrant another comp for another night.
However, the night of the 18th was booked at Cherokee due to poker event, but they showed I had a comp on the 18th for Harrah's Valley River casino an hour away, so I confirmed that reservation and stayed there with comp. I spent 4 days at Harrahs Cherokee resort, and spent enough on tables and slots to be rewarded at least one comp night.